Stuffed Cookies

Our February Assortment is here!

Including new flavors like Nutella Cinnamon Roll, Cookie Butter & Jelly, our classic Red Velvet Cheesecake, and a romantic spin on our classic Oreo Bday Cake.

Shop February Assortment

Introducing our very first, Oreo Bday CAKE! (but actually)

9 Inches of pure deliciousness that will be sure to swoop ur other half off their feet this Valentine's Day. Just choose your message and we'll handle all the rest!

Shop Oreo Bday Cake

This Just in!

Introducing our new Salted Caramel Peanut Butter Pretzel Cookie! For those of you who remember our Recess cookie, this is our new updated version of it and will be available in our classic flavor selection.

Shop Now

The Ultimate Unboxing Experience

With beautiful packaging, opening a box of our cookies not only makes for a delicious experience, but an eye-catching one as well.

Shop Sampler Box

COOKIE BUTTER & JELLY

Our twist on PB&J! This delicious cookie is stuffed with Cookie Butter & homemade strawberry jelly, covered in Speculoos cookie crumbs for an extra crunch, and followed by strawberry dust for an extra tangy punch!

Link to content

Sold out

Oreo Bday Cake Pre-Order

$55.00

FEBRUARY ASSORTMENT

From $22.00

Specialty Assortment

From $33.00

Sampler Box

$59.00

Create Your Own Assortment

$5.50

OUR COOKIES AREN'T ORDINARY COOKIES, THEY'RE STUFFED COOKIES!

What exactly are Stuffed cookies you may ask? They are delicious brown butter based cookies that are filled with gooey centers of Nutella, caramel, peanut butter, and more! We bring you unique combinations and flavors that add a modern twist to your everyday cookie cravings. You have the option to select from our popular assortments or create your own custom box! Although our cookies are all soft, you have the option to pop them into the oven for 4 minutes at 350°F for an unmatched, soft, melt in your mouth, cookie experience. All cookies are approximately 4-6 oz. depending on their flavor, come individually wrapped, and all packaged together ready to gift!

Stuffed with love always!

I started Stuffed as a way to share my passion, creativity, and love of good food with all of you. Each and every single one of these cookies is thoughtfully and individually handcrafted to our vision of perfection. We hope you enjoy them as much as we enjoy baking them for you!

Our story